Mike’s Musings: Judgement Calls

The following is a post written by Saskatoon fencer, and President of the Saskatoon Fencing Club Mike Weaver back in October of 2011, directly following the Asquith Tournament – Looking at officiating from both sides of the piste.

Fencing PHoto by Jessie Jardine

Today is Sunday.  The Asquith Open will have just finished.  I trust it was a great beginning to the year and you all had a good time.  Not being there to participate as either athlete or official, I have no idea what kind of excitements may have occurred.  It was interesting watching the officials at the tournament I was in last weekend.  Some were clearly better than others, but all were doing the best they could to provide consistent, fair officiating.  I didn’t always agree with the official.  For example, I saw a couple of actions called beat attacks when I saw parry repost, but we generally agreed on which way the points should be awarded.

Fencing PHoto by Jessie JardineSome fencers did take exception to some of the calls (big surprise) and, right or wrong, I felt sympathy for the official.  I know from experience that you not only want to make the right calls, you want to be seen to be making the right calls.  In short, you want people to agree with you.  Of course, with a sport like fencing, with lots of judgement calls, there will always be disagreements.  It helps for the official to be supremely self confident, but not everyone is.  The officiating role can be a challenge and yet the sport needs officials.

Fencing PHoto by Jessie JardineThere has never been a fencer that hasn’t disagreed with a call made by an official.  Sometimes, the fencer is right, but often they are not.  I recall a foil pool I was in that was officiated by Kirk Brecht.  It was during the Asquith open several years ago when it was still being held in the Lord Asquith School gym.  Kirk made some terrible calls that, unfortunately, went against me.  Needless to say, I was not impressed.  Never having seen Kirk officiate before, I sat down and watched him work through the rest of the pool.  To my chagrin, I found I was agreeing with all of his calls, even those in which one or the other of the fencers vehemently disagreed.  Kirk is an excellent official although he rarely takes on a foil match.  So, how is it he made such bad calls when I was fencing?  The answer, of course, is that he didn’t.  When we fence, we pay attention to what the other fencer is doing so we can plan good strategy.  When we execute that strategy, we know what we are doing, at least what we intend to do.  However, we are not the only fencer on the piste!  Sometimes our timing is a little off, or our execution fails, or the other fencer steals the time, or something they are trying to do interferes with what we are trying to do.  In those cases, our carefully planned action, which we may think succeeded perfectly, doesn’t look from the sidelines at all like we think it does.  Likewise, the infraction the other fencer so obviously committed may not look like an infraction from the official’s position or it may seem insignificant to what is happening.

Mike Weaver President Saskatoon Fencing Association

Mike Weaver officiating at the Saskatoon Open 2010

When the official makes a wrong call, it is easy to get so fixated on it and so angry that we then screw up several more actions.  If we can be a little more philosophical, we can make other decisions that will be more successful.

On a related note, I have often found myself reluctant to use yellow and red cards as much as I should.  Understanding the fencer’s feelings, I tend to be more tolerant than I should be.  I am coming to understand that the cards are there for the fencer’s benefit as much as for the official.  They are important to the maintenance of good order which is to everyone’s benefit.

Mike Weaver President Saskatoon Fencing Association

Mike Weaver 2010

Mike Weaver


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Cruisin Christine

Adventures of a Saskatchewan Girl

Art Hacker and Creative Advocate

living a creative life

In love with a sex addict…a new perspective

letting my marriage thrive after infidelity

Sundry & Specifics

"Life is either a daring adventure or nothing."~ Helen Keller

Scott Armstrong Photo

The World as I see it.

little box of books

A cozy place to open a collection of words!

Budget Adventure Travel Blog for Working Canadians

Save on Adventure Travels. Ranked Top 40 Calgary Bloggers. Huffington Post AB blogger.

Leland Guillemin

A Canadian fencer chasing a dream!

Just Another Day On The Prairie

The diary and musings of an Alberta ranch wife.

The Plains Explorer

History, Nature, Travel, Lifestyle and Adventure

Hiking Photography

Beautiful photos of hiking and other outdoor adventures.

Posh Pixel Blog

A site about graphic design and branding


life without borders

Sticky Valentines

Words with nowhere else to go.

Jedi Max

Using the force to defeat the Dark Side!


The official Moolta Blog

About The Woman

What Men Should Know


She turns coffee into books so she can afford to buy more coffee. And more books.

%d bloggers like this: